Disappointing stuff about the Pepper Pad 3

You knew this was coming. From the moment I unboxed my Pepper Pad 3 (PP3) six weeks ago, I've been promising a review that was chock full of negativity. It may not be a great way to start off the year, but it was inevitable.

So to complete my alliterative review series, which began with the delightful and continued with the decent, this final PP3 write-up details all of the disappointing (though not disastrous) determinants of the device.

General

Too warm. When plugged in, the right side of the PP3 becomes uncomfortably warm when in use. This may be exclusive to the black unit, though, because I didn't notice the issue with the white one. In fact, while compiling a list of my first impressions with the white device, I jotted down "runs cool." I remember being particularly impressed with this because the PP3 doesn't have any vents. According to Carrypad, this is because it's "passively cooled using a metal heat spreader and natural heat dissipation through the casing."

Hardware

No memory card slot. I always appreciate a memory card slot, regardless of the type. Even though the PP3 has a fine USB import function, I would rather transfer (for example) images directly from my digital camera's memory card than through a separate USB cable or thumb drive.

No hold/lock switch. I know that the PP3 is intended for home use and not for toting around in a gear bag, but the fact that Pepper includes a zippered carrying pouch as an accessory indicates that the device is meant to leave the house sometimes. Without the ability to lock the power button, I need to be very deliberate when packing and traveling with my PP3. Even if I don't plan to use it until I reach my final destination, I have to place it on top of everything else in my bag to avoid the (albeit) off chance of accidentally turning on the system and draining the battery.

No LED indicators. Without at least a HDD indicator, there's no way to tell whether the PP3 is hanging, crashing, or just working slowly. The same is true for the Bluetooth radio; I never know if Bluetooth is on, off, and/or connected to anything.

A dedicated Bluetooth icon next to the battery and Wi-Fi icons ones would work just as well.

Integrated camera. What's the point of the built-in VGA camera? Given its placement above the left keypad, it would be perfect for video chatting . . . if the PP3 were actually capable of recording video. If the camera were designed exclusively for still photography, it would've been on the back of the PP3.

Pepper is supposedly working on adding video functionality, which is great, but I think the feature should’ve been included before launch.

Other

Limited Bluetooth support. This should change eventually, but right now the PP3 supports only mice and keyboards via Bluetooth. Dial-up networking and headset support are not yet available, though I believe the company is making progress in the lab.

Conclusion

Yeah, so this "disappointing stuff" review isn't particularly juicy. And you've probably already guessed why: the Pepper Pad 3 is just about perfect. It still has room for improvement, of course, but not much. If Pepper continues to release outstanding updates, company chief executive Len Kawell may be right in his prediction that devices like the Pepper Pad will one day "be as common in American homes as TVs, with one in nearly every room."

Comments

[Mike Cane]

Some link luv:

http://mikecane.wordpress.com/2007/01/08/pepper-pad-3-disappointments/

[Jenn]

Thanks, Mike!

[Ernesto]

I'd like to buy a PP3 for Sales force Automation.
There's possibility to have WAN card (GPS,GPRS,G3) ?
Where can i buy one in Europe ?
What happens if I'll buy one in USA ?
Did Hanbit released a PP3 version with power button lock ?
Thank you Mr.Jenn for working on mobile units with passion and competence.

[Jenn]

I think EVDO and other USB cards will work with the PP3 once the Bluetooth dial-up networking (DUN) feature is up and running. Several people have had success with BT DUN and the Franklin USB card in particular, but I don't think the functionality is completely ready for release yet. It hasn't appeared as an official update anyway.

International availability is still a bit of a question mark. Your best bet would be to contact Pepper directly or check the Pepper community forums: http://www.pepper.com/forums/index.php

The PP3 is widely available in the U.S. at places like Amazon.com, but you'd have to double-check their international shipping policies.

No, the PP3 has not been released with a power lock. Maybe it'll be on the PP4 :)